Keys to Better Performance Reviews

Posted by | Thursday, November 17, 2016
Keys to Better Performance Reviews

Performance reviews are a key component of effective human resources management, but they are rarely anyone's favorite part of the year.

"For many employees, a face-to-face performance review is the most stressful work conversation they’ll have all year," writes Rebecca Knight in the Harvard Business Review. "For managers, the discussion is just as tense."

Part of the problem is the nature of performance reviews themselves. Inherently, a candid conversation about an employee's work will involve both positives and negatives, and the fact that reviews are often tied to compensation leads to a high-stakes atmosphere that can cause tension on both sides. However, there are steps that smart managers can take to minimize the stress, improve communication between employer and employee, and improve performance and productivity year round.

Be clear ahead of time about your performance expectations.

It is important that you begin looking ahead to the next round of performance reviews as soon as the previous round concludes - or even before. "The performance review doesn't start with a sit-down in the spare conference room," Knight writes. "You must be clear from the outset how you'll evaluate your employees."

Victor Lipman, writing for Forbes, agrees. "If you have clarity about what the objectives are, and better still if the employee is involved in their development, that’s a great starting point."

You may wish to consider hosting smaller, informal meetings during the year with each of your employees in which you share your expectations and solicit their feedback about goals - both yours and theirs. In this way, the end-of-year review becomes just one part of an ongoing conversation about job performance that involves input from both sides.

Consider having a formal mid-year evaluation.

As a supplement to the suggestion above, you may find it is useful to schedule a formal, sit-down evaluation of your employees in the middle of the year. By doing this, you can let your employees know how they are doing and what they need to improve in order to have a good evaluation at the end of the year, when raises, promotions, and other incentives may be on the line.

Lipman notes that having a mid-year evaluation will help keep you on track. He writes, "This will impose rigor on the process and force you to gather the necessary data to make a meaningful assessment – plus it will make the process a whole lot easier when you get to year end."

Another upside to a mid-year evaluation is that it gives your employees an idea what to expect in the end-of-year evaluation, potentially defusing some of the stress that comes with that event.

Help your employees grow through the evaluation process.

It's not enough to just recite a list of the good and bad aspects of your employees' job performance - it is imperative that you show them a path forward to better performance in the future.

"After discussing the strengths and achievements of your solid performers, ask them how they feel about how things are going," Knight writes, noting that most employees will open up with honest concerns and questions. This gives you, as a manager, an opportunity to coach them into better performance.

Knight suggests asking follow-up questions to help them focus on improvement. "What is the employee doing now that is not working? What are they doing that is highly effective? What actions should they adopt to be more so?" she writes. "By focusing on behaviors not dispositions, it takes the personal edge out of the conversation."

Call us today to find out how we can help your business.


Recent Posts

4 Tips for Improving Team Communication

4 Tips for Improving Team Communication

One of the most important aspects of managing a successful team is making sure that there is open communication between all the team members and between them and management. Here are some tips for improving communication in the workplace.  


Use Dale Carnegie’s Advice to Eschew Office Politics and Be Genuine

Use Dale Carnegie’s Advice to Eschew Office Politics and Be Genuine

A lot of people think that it isn't necessary to be genuine when you're in business. In fact, they might even think the opposite: that you're more likely to be successful when you're a little cunning or wily. We all see the effects of flattery, backbiting and scheming. It often seems like the way in which you present yourself is more important than the way you really are. 


Confidence-Improving Techniques to Make You a Phenomenal Human Being

Confidence-Improving Techniques to Make You a Phenomenal Human Being

When we see successful people, we are blown away by how confident they are. They seem so casual when they appear on TV or when they're addressing a group of people. They seem to know what they're talking about when they write essays or answer questions in an interview. They carry themselves with ease. 


First Item First Item

Contact Us Have an HR Question? Get us at:


Stay in touchReceive our best HR tips and tricks via email every month